Skip to content

Yanmar 424 vs Kubota: Which is the Better Compact Tractor?

When it comes to choosing a compact tractor, two popular brands often come to mind: Yanmar and Kubota.

Both brands have a reputation for producing high-quality and durable machines, but which one is the better choice?

In this article, we will compare Yanmar 424 and Kubota tractors in terms of their features, performance, and overall value.

Yanmar 424 and Kubota: Overview

Before diving into the comparison, let’s take a quick look at the specifications and features of each tractor.

Yanmar 424

The Yanmar 424 is a 24-horsepower compact tractor that is designed for small to medium-sized properties. It features a three-cylinder diesel engine, a hydrostatic transmission, and a Category 1 three-point hitch. Other notable features include:

  • Maximum lifting capacity of 1,100 pounds
  • Turning radius of 7.2 feet
  • Four-wheel drive
  • Mid-PTO and rear-PTO options
  • Optional loader and backhoe attachments

Kubota

Kubota offers a range of compact tractors, but for the purposes of this comparison, we will focus on the BX series, which is similar in size and power to the Yanmar 424. The BX series includes models like the BX1880, BX2380, and BX2680. These tractors feature:

  • 18 to 25 horsepower diesel engines
  • Hydrostatic transmissions
  • Three-point hitches
  • Four-wheel drive
  • Optional loader and backhoe attachments

Comparison: Yanmar 424 vs Kubota

Now that we have a basic understanding of each tractor, let’s compare them in terms of their features and performance.

Engine

Both Yanmar and Kubota use diesel engines in their compact tractors, but there are some differences in the engines they offer. The Yanmar 424 has a three-cylinder engine with a displacement of 1.1 liters, while the Kubota BX series has engines ranging from 0.9 to 1.3 liters in displacement. While both brands are known for producing reliable engines, the Yanmar engine has a slightly larger displacement, which could result in more power and torque.

Winner: Yanmar 424

Transmission

The Yanmar 424 comes standard with a hydrostatic transmission, while the Kubota BX series also uses hydrostatic transmissions. Hydrostatic transmissions offer smooth and easy operation, but some users prefer manual transmissions for more precise control. However, Yanmar’s hydrostatic transmission is well-regarded for its durability and efficiency.

Winner: Tie

Four-Wheel Drive

Both Yanmar and Kubota offer four-wheel drive as a standard feature on their compact tractors. Four-wheel drive provides better traction and stability on uneven terrain, which is especially important for farming and landscaping applications.

Winner: Tie

Loader and Backhoe Attachments

Both Yanmar and Kubota offer optional loader and backhoe attachments for their compact tractors, which can significantly expand their versatility and usefulness. However, the availability and compatibility of these attachments may vary depending on the specific model of tractor.

Winner: Tie

Price

One significant factor to consider when comparing Yanmar and Kubota compact tractors is the price. Generally speaking, Yanmar tractors tend to be slightly more expensive than Kubota tractors. However, the price difference may be worth it for some users if they value the Yanmar’s larger engine and other features.

Winner: Kubota

Conclusion

So, which compact tractor is better: Yanmar 424 or Kubota? It’s a tough call, as both brands offer high-quality and reliable machines that are well-suited for a variety of applications. Ultimately, the choice between Yanmar and Kubota may come down to personal preference, budget, and the specific needs of the user.

FAQs

  1. Which compact tractor is more fuel-efficient, Yanmar or Kubota?
  • Both Yanmar and Kubota are known for producing efficient diesel engines, so fuel efficiency may be comparable between the two brands.
  1. Can I use third-party attachments with a Yanmar or Kubota compact tractor?
  • It’s possible, but it’s important to make sure that the attachments are compatible with the tractor’s specifications and mounting points.
  1. Is it necessary to have four-wheel drive on a compact tractor?
  • While four-wheel drive is not strictly necessary, it can provide better traction and stability in challenging terrain, making it a useful feature for farming and landscaping applications.
  1. How long can I expect a Yanmar or Kubota compact tractor to last?
  • With proper maintenance and care, both Yanmar and Kubota compact tractors can last for many years and thousands of hours of operation.
  1. Can I finance a Yanmar or Kubota compact tractor?
  • Yes, both Yanmar and Kubota offer financing options for their compact tractors, which can make it easier to afford these high-quality machines.